I’m Really a Superstar Chapter 307: [dumb speechless! 】

Short silence.

"It's still wrong"

"This view is untenable"

"Yes, it can't be written by Gao Yan"

"Although there is no evidence, but what evidence is there?"

A lot of people who are not elective courses of "Appreciation of the Classics" also talked about it, but at this time, everyone also felt that this class was worth it, because regardless of the perspective of Zhang Ye, this public class uses **** I also want to know that it will definitely make a splash in the education and Literature circles.

Xueba Senior Song has been standing so she hasn't sat down at all, because she still has to stand up and ask questions after sitting down, which is too troublesome. She has too many questions about the view of Zhang Ye. I saw her raise her hand, and Speak directly, "I'm sorry Teacher Zhang Ye, I still can't accept your point of view. The evidence for the last forty times is Gao Ye's work is still not enough to explain the problem. There is too little information, too much imagination out of thin air, and Gao Ye is responsible for organizing books. People do n’t have the literacy to write Dream of the Building, and it ’s impossible to continue writing so well. "

Zhang Ye shook his finger, "Xiao Song, you are wrong."

"Why?" Senior Song asked back.

Other Peking University teachers and students also look at Zhang Ye.

Zhang Ye vowed again and again, "Gao Ye has the literacy and conditions to continue to write the dream of the building," and in that era, I think only Gao Ye has the huh, don't look at me like this, you are right Gao Zhi's understanding may not be enough. Mostly, he only knows that he is a organizer, but he doesn't know his other background. If you don't believe it, well, I just demonstrated it from the perspective of the data, and I will say it from the perspective of emotions. Say, um, this paragraph is actually not the point. You can listen or not. Do you want to listen? "

"Think"

"Sure to listen"

"A must"

Senior Song also nodded.

Disagree is disagree, but everyone still wants to hear.

Zhang Ye, yeah, "Then I will briefly talk about it, Gao Ling has been holding the title of saver communicator and organizer. In fact, many people are unclear. In fact, Gao Ling's Literature literacy is his most glorious. . "He saw the following Professor Zeng slightly nodded and said:" Professor Zeng seems to understand. "

Professor Zeng affirmed: "Teacher Zhang is right, and appreciate whatever you have in mind-this is what people of that era think of Gao Yong."

Zhang Ye laughed: "That's it. Gao Ling is a very talented person. He can summarize Gao Ling's life with distressed and talented eight characters, which makes him similar to Cao Xueqin. Life experience, the stagnation of the field in the early years, and the dull career in his later years kept him in a tragic and distressed psychological experience, which enabled him to understand and stay close to Cao Xueqin emotionally, and complete that touching tragedy ending. In addition, we only need to turn It can be known from looking at the information that Gao Yong is loyal, and often encourages and disciples to exercise loyalty and filial piety. His eight-stroke writing is well written, his thinking is strong, and his writing skills are strong. In the poems He also often paints the sentimental feelings of life like a dream with a layer of Buddha's color. All of these can be felt faintly in the forty times after the dream of Lou, so from the perspective of feelings, Gao Ling was in that era The person who is best suited to continue to write Dream of the Building, he is also capable of doing it "

A meal, Zhang Ye said: "I said that the red mansion written by Gao Ai was a bit out of step with the front, but it was just a difference in personal style. I did not deny Gao Ai. On the contrary, I still respect him, and he is a red man. I continued to write the ending, which facilitated the widespread dissemination of Lou Meng, and Gao Ye made a great contribution.

Why is it more true?

An Peking University senior student from the history department suddenly raised his hand and said, "All of what you said is based on the premise that people continue to write after 80 times in Lou Meng." I don't think it is an argument now. The continuation of Gao Yong's writing is still a problem for some anonymous name, but ... Why do you say Lou Meng? Only 80 times are Mr. Cao Xueqin's manuscript? Why do you say 120 Dreams? Written instead of Mr. Cao Xueqin's original work? Is it based on a poem of the Qing Dynasty poet and a note with eighty words? "

Zhang Ye said with a smile: "You're quite excited."

The history student dumbfounded , "Couldn't you be excited, what you said is too subversive. Have you co-authored our history lessons for so many years? Have you made a low-level education in co-authoring the entire Republic? Wrong? Did n’t even the author of Lou Meng, one of the four famous works? "

This is the main reason why you do n’t believe Zhang Ye

So many experts, so many scholars, is everyone wrong? It's impossible

Although the truth is often in the hands of a few people, you are too few people. You are the one who holds this view.

An authority in education and academia.

A Zhang Ye, Literature circle streaming Host circle.

Who do you think is more trustworthy? The answer already is clear at a glance, you do n’t need to ask.

"We have no evidence to refute you ..."

"Yes, but you can't refute our point of view"

Just like "Journey to the West", you have to say that this book was actually not written by Wu Chengen, but was written by Wu Chengen's twin brother. His twin brother was also named Wu Chengen since he was a child, but only Wu Chengen's family. The talent knows that Wu Chengen is not Wu Chengen but his brother and others do not know that this Wu Chengen is not that Wu Chengen but he thinks that Wu Chengen is Wu Chengen-is that all right? If someone publishes this view, others can't refute it without evidence, then should the author of Journey to the West also change?

That way, the Literature world is not messy anymore

But Zhang Ye said, "Who says I have no evidence to refute?"

Chou Xuechang, a junior in the Chinese Department, said, "But you just have all the information ..."

Hehe smiled, Zhang Ye said: "It was just an opening to help everyone enter the atmosphere. Since I dare to let go of this, naturally I have other evidence and information to support it, so first of all, I want to ask you one thing, Lou The earliest ancient editions of "Dream", in addition to the version compiled by Gao Ye, whether it is this edition or that edition, do the earliest ancient editions passed down contain more than eighty stories? "

Everyone stays.

"Are you there?"

"I don't know."

"Well, wait for me to search"

Students have started to check out cell phone.

Professor Zeng is also frowning, eyes closed meditation, remember.

An Peking University student from the liberal arts department suddenly said, "Yes, here is an ancient book that is 120 times old."

Zhang Ye laughed. "This classmate, then you can check it again. In what age is this ancient text printed and issued? I can tell you that the original of this ancient text is only thirty-five. People supplemented the printing and distribution after 179l and changed it. It was added intact according to Gao Yan's version. "He also did a lot of homework.

The students of the liberal arts department checked it, and they didn't speak after sweating, really.

Professor Zeng and Chang Kaige Zhen Shuquan all have a few of them, weird, really not.

Zhang Ye said: "So the most complete ancient text you have ever read is the one compiled by Gao Yong. It was printed and issued in 179. Then I have a question. Why haven't all ancient texts appeared in the 80s before? Back to the future story? Even one copy is fine, why is it so in eight books and ten books? "

Yao Mi spoke, "Too much destruction because Guben lost?"

The Preservation of the Ancient Dream of the World is indeed a terrible one.

But Zhang Ye said: "But it ’s too coincidental? Do n’t you all have this doubt? Some of the ancient texts have only a dozen times left, and some more, forty or fifty times, but these ratios are higher. The old version, which is much older, has not recorded the story after eighty times. In 179l, all of a sudden the Dream of Loulou suddenly appeared, and one hundred and twenty times the complete ancient version came out.It can also be seen from a logical perspective. Is it too weird to come out? If Cao Xueqin wrote it for the last forty times, why wouldn't anyone other than Cheng Weiyuan and Gao Xuan transcribe it? And no one else would get it from the drums? The length, even if you ca n’t copy it all, you can transcribe a part of it. But before Cheng Weiyuan and Gao Ling, no one copied out even the text attached to the first eighty times?

This question asked a lot of people at once

Even a few who have studied Peking University Teacher who have studied Dream of the Building for a while