Judge of the Song Dynasty Chapter 307: Rescue

Bad?

Fan Chunren tilted his head to look at Zhang Fei, "What do you mean?"

Zhang Fei said solemnly: "If you can't expose the ugliest side of Huang Laoer, the chances of winning this lawsuit will be much smaller."

This lawsuit is an extrajudicial affair, so this affection must be in place, otherwise, it will be difficult for affection to break through the boundaries of the law.

Fan Chunren pondered for a while: "The presiding officer must have asked the right questions, otherwise, you don't need to appeal. The judge standing next to you will definitely reject the presiding officer's judgment."

"This is different!"

Zhang Fei shook his head.

Fan Chunren asked, "What's the difference?"

Zhang Fei said: "Er Bi is aggressive and can set traps in the question, while the presiding judge asks questions in a fair manner and is not offensive. He just raises his own questions based on doubts. , it is easy for the other party to guess, and they could have thought of a countermeasure in advance, which is difficult to expose the ugliest side of the other party."

Fan Chunren nodded slightly, and asked again: "Then which interrogation method do you think is more fair?"

Zhang Fei smiled and said, "Needless to say, of course it is the former."

"Why?" Fan Chunren asked.

Zhang Fei said: "Because both parties will do their best to protect their client and at the same time spare no effort to attack the other party. This is almost certain. If the chief interrogator asks questions."

He tilted his head to look at Fan Chunren, and said with a smile: "Fan Sijian and I have fought two lawsuits, and we should know that many questions seem to be fair, but when asked at different times and in different order, the results obtained The effect is very different."

Fan Chunren frowned and said nothing.

He is the only one who feels deeply about this.

Because he has fought against Zhang Fei before, he has to hide many issues that are beneficial to him, and wait for the opponent to make a move first, and then raise it to refute, if he raises it first, he may be countered by the opponent.

If the presiding officer takes the lead, who knows what he is thinking and what his purpose for asking this question is.

Xu Zhiqian, who was in the hall, also felt something was wrong. Judging by Liang Dong's attitude, she didn't know how much room she would give them.

In the previous interrogation method, Erbi was also qualified to ask questions, but the main line was controlled by the judge, and Erbi could only make a plea based on the judge's questions.

Sure enough.

When Huang Yongli came to the hall, Liang Dong asked directly: "Huang Yongli, as an only son, why don't you take your elderly mother to live with you?"

Because the Song Dynasty attached great importance to filial piety, in the "Song Xingtong", there is such a rule that if there is a lack of support from a different family, it can be considered a crime of unfilial piety.

That is to say, when the parents are old, the children divide the parents' property privately and set up a separate family, which leads to the children not fulfilling their responsibility to support their parents.

This crime carries a maximum penalty of death.

Therefore, no matter how ruthless Huang Yongli is, he would not dare to sell the house while his mother was alive.

Liang Dong had to question this point when he came up.

Huang Yongli immediately complained: "The official has learned that the villain is wronged. After my father passed away, the villain always wanted to take his mother to live with the villain, but the mother is used to living in the old house and has always refused. Living with the villain, the villain even argued with his mother a few times because of this.”

Xu Zhiqian immediately said: "If you are really filial, why did you never show up for your mother's birthday in the past few years?"

Huang Yongli looked sad, shook his head and said: "This is indeed my negligence. All these years, I have focused on making money to support my family, and neglected my mother's birthday. I am really unfilial!"

As he spoke, he choked with sobs and wiped his eyes.

Li Lei on the opposite side immediately said: "Regarding this point, Si Lu can send someone to ask, Huang Yongli is so busy every day, he gets up early and sleeps late every day, and often forgets his own birthday. Mrs. Xu has been pampered since she was a child, and she naturally understands It is not worth the hard work of the common people."

Xu Zhiqian was also forced to change the subject of the question, and said to Liang Dong: "If Silu knew what Huang Yongli was doing on the eighth day of the seventh month two years ago, he would know that what he said was all lies and could not be trusted."

These questions were originally used to ask Huang Yongli, but now she can only go directly to persuade the chief interrogator.

Liang Dong asked Huang Yongli: "What were you doing on the eighth day of the seventh lunar month two years ago?"

Huang Yongli thought about it, and said with a little guilty conscience: "That day seems to be the villain's 30th birthday."

Liang Dong immediately looked at Li Lei.

Huang Yongli immediately explained: "That's what the villain's wife has to do, it has nothing to do with the villain!"

Xu Zhiqian asked again: "Did you invite your mother to go there that day?"

Huang Yongli replied: "Of course I invited, but my mother refused to come."

Of course he didn't, but such a thing is hard to prove.

Xu Zhiqian said: "The only son's 30th birthday, the mother refused to come, can Uncle Huang explain why?"

After listening to Li Lei, a look of joy flashed in his eyes.

Huang Yongli said: "Didn't I say it before, I argued with my mother several times before, and she was angry with me."

Xu Zhiqian was just about to continue asking, but Liang Dong asked first: "You kindly took your mother to live with you, no matter what, it is considered filial piety. Even if your mother is unwilling, she shouldn't be angry with you. Tell me honestly." , Is there something else hidden in it?"

Xu Zhiqian saw that Liang Dong's question was reasonable, so she kept silent.

Huang Yongli glanced at Liang Dong with a guilty conscience, and said: "The villain dare not lie to the officials. In fact, the villain wanted to take his mother to live in the villain's house, and then sold the old house."

"Bastard!"

Liang Dong immediately reprimanded: "In the final analysis, you don't want to be filial at all, but want to seek your parents' property. It's really unreasonable."

Li Lei immediately said: "Si Lu Mingjian, in fact, the two are not in conflict. Huang Yongli really wants to sell the old house, because this is actually killing two birds with one stone for him. Get a sum of money and take your business to the next level."

Liang Dong said: "You are purely sophistry, can't you be filial if you don't sell this old house?"

Li Lei was silent.

Huang Yongli also bowed his head guiltily.

Liang Dong patted the gavel, and scolded: "Don't you hurry up and get it from the truth?"

Huang Yongli said: "Small man. The villain wants to take his mother to live with him. It is indeed selfish, but the villain also really wants to take his mother to live with him."

Li Lei explained again: "Silu, it is natural for mother and son to have some disputes. Although Huang Yongli was unfilial, he still respected his mother's wishes and did not force her to sell the house."

Liang Dong nodded slightly.

Xu Zhiqian was completely dumbfounded. After Liang Dong's questions, she didn't even have a chance to intervene. Liang Dong had completely disrupted her rhythm.

Liang Dong's questions seemed fair, but in fact he followed the other party's answer and asked, rather than questioning.

It seems that it is not good for Huang Yongli, but it has been proved from the side that Huang Yongli actually wants to take his mother to live with him. No matter what the reason is, at least he has this plan.

Although filial piety is mixed with benefits, who can figure out how much filial piety accounts for and how much benefits account for.

And he can use his quarrel with his mother to explain many of his unfilial behaviors.

Mother and son are angry, if you say they are not filial, it is also considered unfilial, and the son should give in to his mother. For scholars, this will definitely be criticized by others, but for ordinary people, this is also human nature.

Definitely not a heinous crime.

You can tell a thing or two from the attitude of the people watching the trial at the gate.

No one was very angry.

Some people are even thinking, this old woman is really too stubborn, and it is not easy for her son to do business. You live with your son, which is good for you and good for your son.

Xu Zhiqian was a little flustered immediately. The situation was already very unfavorable to her. Whether Huang Yongli invited him to be the current Patriarch had already been determined by Liang Dong. If it couldn't be reversed, it would be very troublesome.

However, Liang Dongcai

It's the presiding officer, he won't accommodate these Er pens, he just waited for a while, seeing that Xu Zhiqian was silent, he said loudly: "Brief to Mrs. Liu and Wu."

Xu Zhiqian was taken aback, and hurriedly said: "Si Lu, I... I haven't finished asking?"

Liang Dong asked with a smile: "Do you have any questions?"

Xu Zhiqian hadn't thought of a countermeasure yet.

Liang Dong said very tolerantly: "Here you are, you can ask later when you think about it." Then he ordered: "First pass on Liu Wu."

Fan Chunren, who was watching from the sidelines, saw that Zhang Fei was sweating profusely, and couldn't help laughing: "Maybe you were right before, but this also proves that as long as you change the interrogation method, your method will not work." now."

Zhang Fei suddenly had an idea, he laughed and said, "I can't? If Fan Sijian can guarantee that I won't be punished later, I can immediately turn the situation around and nail Huang Yongli to death."

Fan Chunren was very curious and asked, "What are you going to do?"

Zhang Feiyun said lightly: "I just shouted a few words. That's enough."

Fan Chunren really doesn't believe it, if you shout a few words, you can turn things around, do you think you are a god? I thought, shouting a few words is not a serious crime, so I nodded and said: "Okay! If you only shout a few words, I guarantee you will not be punished."

"Look! Don't blink!"

After Zhang Fei said that, he rushed over, jumped up, and cursed angrily: "Huang Yongli, you are not as good as pigs and dogs! You did not hesitate to kill your own mother in order to sell the house, a murderer! You are a mother murderer."

He yelled, and everyone was shocked.

A murderer?

Kill your mother?

Really?

One of the officials was the first to react, and hurriedly ordered the servants, "Stop him, stop him quickly!"

In an instant, two yamen servants rushed over and stopped Zhang Fei. While struggling, Zhang Fei shouted, "Huang Yongli, you bastard, your mother has been suffering from illnesses for the past two years, but you **** Turning a blind eye and not even inviting a doctor, it turned out that you wished for your mother to die sooner, so that you could sell the house sooner."

Huang Yongli panicked and retorted subconsciously: "I didn't! You wronged me!"

You idiot. Zhang Fei shouted: "I wronged you? Did you take your mother to see a doctor? Did you pay for your mother's medical treatment? You are a beast worse than a pig and a dog. For money, you even killed your mother." But you didn't expect it, Granny Huang has already seen through your thoughts, she would rather give the house to others than to you, and you will be mad at you, haha, retribution, retribution! Hahaha!"

Liang Dong also reacted, and was furious, "How did this guy come in? Let me catch him quickly, it is really unreasonable, dare to play tricks in my courtroom, I have to do it today. !"

"Sorry! Sorry!"

Fan Chunren ran over suddenly, panting: "Liang Silu, I brought him in. I am so sorry for disturbing Liang Silu's trial. I will take him away now."

Liang Dong looked at Fan Chunren, he didn't look at the monk's face, he had to look at the Buddha's face, the key point is that he is an admonisher, and he specializes in impeaching officials. This kind of favor has to be sold, so he coughed: "Fan Sijian, quickly take him Get out of here."

"Yes, yes! Another day, Fan will come to the door to plead guilty."

Fan Chunren cupped his hands again and again, feeling very guilty, and then pulled Zhang Fei outside, teaching him a lesson as he walked.

Where is Zhang Fei listening? Turning around, he secretly winked at Xu Zhiqian.

Out of the door, Fan Chunren excitedly said: "You are wronging people."

Zhang Fei argued: "Why did I wrong someone? Didn't Fan Sijian hear that just now? He admitted that it was for money. Then Fan Sijian thought about it. His mother died of illness. Who is the biggest beneficiary? He can finally get the house he wished for."

Fan Chunren said: "You are just speculating, there is no evidence."

Zhang Fei nodded and said: "I guess, then Liang Silu won't listen to me either! Hehe."