Judge of the Song Dynasty Chapter 208: Easy to know but hard to do

Zhang Fei's yelling immediately aroused a lot of discussion among the onlookers at the door.

Killing your mother for money?

This crime is very serious right now!

A thousand cuts by a thousand cuts is not an exaggeration.

Narbi and Li Lei are not good at it either. He also knows that the opinions of the common people are extremely important in this lawsuit, so he is very angry. You two are really shameless for playing this trick, so he hurriedly said to Liang Dong: " Liang Silu, they.!"

As soon as Liang Dong raised his hand, he signaled him to be calm and not to be impatient, and then told Tang Lu: "You don't need to memorize what the lunatic just said, and you can't count it."

Tang Lu nodded.

Liang Dong glared at Xu Zhiqian again, but Xu Zhiqian kept frowning tightly and clenched her hands tightly into fists, so she didn't notice his angry gaze at all.

Slapping the gavel, Liang Dong shouted loudly: "Quiet!"

It was quiet at the door.

Xu Zhiqian also woke up with a start, her vermilion lips parted slightly, and she gasped slightly, suddenly feeling that her back was already drenched.

Ome, who was at the side, quietly handed over a silk handkerchief, "Sister Qian'er."

Xu Zhiqian took it and wiped it on her face casually, thinking, it's so dangerous! What a risk! Fortunately, Zhang San is here, otherwise...!

At this moment, Aunt Liu came to the hall.

Liang Dong still asked as usual: "Liu Wu, have you been taking care of Granny Huang next door to your house for the past two or three years?"

"If you are a Huiguan, yes." Aunt Liu nodded tremblingly.

Liang Dong asked: "You are not related to her, why should you take care of her?"

Xu Zhiqian immediately frowned and looked at Liang Dong. This question was obviously biased. But after thinking about it, just now Zhang Fei played an outside trick, and Liang Dong was a bit biased, which is reasonable.

Aunt Liu said: "I just see that my aunt lives alone and has no one to take care of her. It's so pitiful. We are neighbors and we can help a little."

Liang Dong nodded, and asked Aunt Liu: "Then have you ever thought that she will give you the house?"

Aunt Liu shook her head again and again: "I never thought about it that way."

"You lied!"

Li Lei suddenly yelled, pointed at Aunt Liu and said, "You clearly plotted against Granny Huang's house, and for this reason you deliberately alienated the relationship between their mother and child."

Aunt Liu panicked and shouted: "I didn't, don't blame me."

Li Lei said: "Did you say that Granny Huang told you that her son Huang Yongli forced her to tell outsiders that she herself did not want to live in his son's house."

Aunt Liu said: "This is indeed what my aunt told me, I am not lying."

Li Lei hummed: "Can someone prove it?"

Aunt Liu said: "At that time, I was alone by the side, except for my aunt, I was the only one who knew."

Li Lei asked again: "When Granny Huang transferred the ownership of the house to you, did she already fall ill in bed and couldn't even get out of bed."

Aunt Liu nodded.

Li Lei asked again: "Aside from you and the notary Uncle Niu, were there any relatives of Granny Huang present?"

Aunt Liu shook her head.

Li Lei immediately said to Liang Dong: "Liang Silu, the facts are already very obvious. It is clear that Mrs. Liu and Wu coveted Granny Huang's house, and deliberately provoked the relationship between their mother and child, and then took advantage of Granny Huang's illness. She transferred the house to herself."

Aunt Liu had never been to court before, and when she saw this man talking nonsense with her eyes open, she yelled anxiously: "I have never provoked the relationship between their mother and child. It was Granny Huang who asked Uncle Niu to call me over that day, and I didn't instigate it either. Don't believe me." Ask Uncle Niu."

Xu Zhiqian suddenly said: "Auntie, don't worry. Let me ask you, how long has Granny Huang been sick."

When Aunt Liu saw Xu Zhiqian, she felt a little more at ease, and replied, "But I have been ill for a year or two."

Xu Zhiqian asked again: "Does his son know?"

Aunt Liu glanced at Huang Yongli and said, "I know, Huang Dalang also came here a few times during the period."

Xu Zhiqian

Ask: "Did his son ask a doctor to treat his mother?"

"But never!" Aunt Liu shook her head and said very aggrieved: "Later, when I saw that my mother's illness was getting worse, I even went to him, and wanted him to invite a doctor to treat my mother's illness. He ignored me."

Huang Yongli retorted: "You are lying, you have never looked for me."

Aunt Liu argued: "I have already gone to you."

Knowing that it is difficult to prove this, Xu Zhiqian hurriedly said, "Auntie, don't argue with him. Let me ask you again, has Granny Huang's illness not been healed?"

The more Aunt Liu spoke, the more aggrieved she became, her words choked with sobs: "Later, I hired a doctor with my family's savings and prescribed a few medicines, but it got better for a while."

Xu Zhiqian said: "Has Huang Yongli never given money to his mother?"

Aunt Liu shook her head, "He didn't even send a single grain of rice."

Li Lei immediately said: "This is just your side story, you have evidence."

Aunt Liu said: "I live next door, I don't know yet."

"But you have no evidence to prove this." Li Lei said.

Aunt Liu asked: "What evidence?"

Xu Zhiqian used to go to court with Zhang Fei, and the other party was also very polite, but now she was always interrupted by Li Lei, and she couldn't get used to it for a while, so she quickly asked, "Auntie, when did Huang Yongli learn about his mother?" died?"

Aunt Liu looked at Xu Zhiqian again, and said, "I saw that my aunt was dying, so I asked my son to go and told Huang Dalang, and his family rushed over immediately, but unfortunately we didn't see the last one."

Xu Zhiqian said: "When did Huang Yongli mention this house?"

Aunt Liu said: "I was asking that day. I said that my aunt gave me the house. He said that I robbed his house and asked me to return it to him. If he didn't return it, he would sue me."

Xu Zhiqian suddenly asked Li Lei, "Does Li Er know when Huang Yongli came to your store for help?"

Li Lei frowned and looked at Xu Zhiqian. After a while, he said: "This is the tenth day of the month."

Xu Zhiqian said: "Then do you know that two days ago, on the eighth day of the lunar new year, Huang Yongli went to Bianjing Law Firm, and it was after Bianjing Law Firm rejected him that he went to your store .”

Li Lei shook his head and said, "I don't know."

Xu Zhiqian said to Liang Dong again: "Grandma Huang passed away on the seventh day of the first day, that is, on the second day after Granny Huang passed away, Huang Yongli immediately sought someone to file a lawsuit."

Liang Dong nodded slightly, then glanced at the two wardens, and saw that they were memorizing while shaking their heads.

Xu Zhiqian took out a piece of paper, "This is the diagnosis and prescription written by the doctor at that time, which is enough to prove that Granny Huang did not suffer from an incurable disease, but died of a long illness without treatment. Granny Huang will not die so soon."

"Submitted."

A yamen servant took the diagnosis and prescription, but not to Liang Dong, but to the medical officer next to him.

The medical officer nodded towards Liang Dong after looking at it.

Seeing this, Li Lei also began to sweat.

Xu Zhiqian said: "Just now Huang Yongli said that he had a slight dispute with his mother, but the facts have proved that the matter is not so simple. After a few disputes, how can we see that my mother is sick but not ask a doctor to treat her? In the end, the neighbors help Please get a doctor.

But after his mother passed away, not only did he not feel any guilt, but he immediately asked Erbi to file a lawsuit, trying to get back the house. It can be seen that Huang Yongli only thought about the house in his heart. For this reason, he not only quarreled with his mother, He even hoped that his mother would die sooner, which is really a vain son of man. "

"That's right! My mother just passed away, even if the sky falls, I should stay in front of the coffin instead of rushing to find someone to fight a lawsuit. This Huang Dalang is clearly lying."

"Tsk tsk. I never thought there would be such vicious people in the world."

"It's more than just being a son of man in vain, it's simply not as good as a beast."

The people at the gate began to discuss again.

Huang Yongli saw it in his eyes, but he was anxious in his heart, "Don't you want to spout blood, that house

The child will be mine sooner or later, why should I be in a hurry. "

Xu Zhiqian sneered and said: "Didn't you just say that if you sell the house, your business will be improved, so it shows that you really want the house very urgently."

"Me!"

Huang Yongli is really suffering.

That was made up, he didn't need money urgently, he just disliked his mother who was old and sick, and didn't want to support him, he thought, he was the only son, the house would be his sooner or later.

Li Lei was complaining incessantly, this was really shooting himself in the foot, and hurriedly said to Liang Dong: "Mother Huang knows that her son has to earn money to support the family, and is very busy. She doesn't want to worry her son, and it is human nature to hide his illness. As for He said that Huang Yongli was in a hurry to find someone to fight the lawsuit because he was very angry. He firmly believed that his mother would never transfer the ownership of the house to Liu Wu. When dying, if you don’t think about your grandson, you can see that Mrs. Liu and Wu are lying.”

At present, Er Bi is still used to all kinds of sophistry, and doesn't pay much attention to evidence. After all, he doesn't make much money, so he doesn't have so much time to investigate evidence.

But their set has obviously fallen behind.

"It's not that Aunt Liu is lying, but that Granny Huang is completely desperate for her son."

Xu Zhiqian said to Liang Dong: "Liang Silu, it's not that Granny Huang suddenly became ill, but she was ill for a year or two. Everyone in the neighborhood knew about it. During this period, Huang Yongli visited many times. Although there are not many, if you really have the heart, it is impossible not to find out. It can be seen that Huang Yongli hates because of profit, and he will not save him.

As for Granny Huang's two grandsons, that is, Huang Yongli's two sons. Although according to the law of our dynasty, they all have the right to inherit, they are all innocent, after all, they are still young and do not know the world.

However, my goal of legislation is not only to punish evil, but also to promote good. If the government awards the house to his two grandsons, it is equivalent to awarding Huang Yongli, then everyone will not care about filial piety in the future, but will only use their sons to compete for their parents' property. This is definitely not what the court wants to see .

Therefore, I hereby implore Si Lu to obey Granny Huang's last wish and award the house to the kind-hearted Liu Wu. At the same time, I also use this matter to warn Granny Huang's two grandsons not to learn from their father, but to be filial to their parents . "

"Well said!"

A woman in the corridor couldn't help applauding.

Liang Dong frowned, and was about to slap the gavel, when there was another burst of shouting and cursing from the gate.

"For an old house, even the mother's life is ignored, this kind of person should be damned!"

"Zhang Sanlang is right, this man is really inferior to a beast."

"He still has the face to use his two sons as an excuse. Maybe his son will do the same to him when he gets old."

Fan Chunren, who was waiting outside the door, heard the people shouting and cursing at the door, and couldn't help saying to Zhang Fei: "It seems that your plan has succeeded."

Zhang Fei said with a smile: "They brought it to the door themselves. In fact, we don't have any evidence to prove that Huang Yongli ignored his mother for the sake of the house. He himself admitted it."

Fan Chunren asked: "If you were asked to help Huang Yongli in the lawsuit, what would you do?"

Zhang Fei glanced at him and said, "Fan Sijian can't win."

Fan Chunren said, "Really?"

Zhang Fei said with a smile: "I will let Huang Yongli's wife come out to file a lawsuit and let Huang Yongli confess his mistakes. After all, they are looking for money, not face."

Fan Chunren couldn't help frowning, he never expected that Zhang Fei would do such a trick, and scolded: "Despicable."

Zhang Fei spread his hands and said, "Despicable and not illegal."

Fan Chunren said: "Why not break the law, you instigated his wife to lie in court."

Zhang Fei chuckled and said, "His wife doesn't need to lie, she can also push the responsibility to Huang Yongli in court. Who knows about the affairs between their husband and wife. It's hard for an upright official to decide on family affairs. As long as the court If it is impossible to prove that Huang Yongli is not filial, then it is beneficial to him, and his two sons can play a huge role at this time, and it may be to compensate Aunt Liu hundreds of dollars."

Fan Chunren nodded: "Really

It is difficult for an upright official to decide on housework. "

If Huang Yongli's wife was brought in, it would be difficult to tell clearly, and it would be difficult for the judge to determine whether it was the wife who refused to let the husband take the mother to live, or the husband himself was unwilling to go.

Only the two of them know about this.

As long as the responsibility is blurred, it will be very beneficial to Huang Yongli.

Actually, Li Lei also came up with this idea, because Huang Yongli's style was really too much, but he hoped to use the house to blur Huang Yongli's responsibility, and at the same time emphasized the ownership of the house, but he was bitten by the other party.

At this moment, Li Si suddenly ran over, "Third brother, Mrs. Xu and the others have come out."

Zhang Fei looked up and saw Xu Zhiqian and Qingmei walking out.

Fan Chunren said to Zhang Fei: "I'll go first."

"Fan Sijian walks slowly."

A moment after Fan Chunren left, Xu Zhiqian walked over quickly.

Zhang Fei asked: "How is the sentence?"

Xu Zhiqian shook her head: "I'm afraid I have to wait until the afternoon."

As she spoke, she looked at Zhang Fei again with a red face, and said in a voice like a mosquito: "It's really thanks to you."

Zhang Fei said solemnly: "Except for the gratitude promised by the body, the rest will not be accepted. I almost got a board."

Xu Zhiqian raised her hand and patted it lightly, "I'm serious with you."

Zhang Fei easily held the catkin she sent, and said with a smile: "Speaking seriously, if I'm not afraid that you will suffer too much, I really don't want to help you."

Xu Zhiqian asked, "Why?"

Zhang Fei said: "Because you have turned a very professional job of litigation into a **** in the green forest to help the weak."

Xu Zhiqian asked suspiciously: "Isn't that right?"

"Of course not."

Zhang Fei said: "There is only one principle in litigation, which is to protect the interests of the parties involved. You may only help the weak, or you may not charge money, but this principle cannot be changed."

Xu Zhiqian shook her head and said, "I don't really understand."

Zhang Fei said: "For example, in this lawsuit, you never thought of negotiating with Huang Yongli, because you think that people like Huang Yongli should be punished, and there is no room for negotiation. But the fact is that this case went to court. , Aunt Liu has to bear the risk, she may get less, or even be falsely accused.

You are not guaranteed to win. If you do this, you will violate the principle of protecting the interests of the parties. You just want to eliminate the strong and help the weak, but objectively speaking, this is just your selfish desire, not Aunt Liu's wish. Maybe losing the lawsuit might be more helpful to you. Unfortunately, I didn't make up my mind. "

Xu Zhiqian choked up and said, "You tell me now, it's the same."

Zhang Fei rolled his eyes: "What is the same, I have said so many times, have you heard of it?"

Xu Zhiqian's eyes turned red suddenly, "I listened this time. Really."

Seeing that she was about to cry, Zhang Fei couldn't help being startled, "What's wrong?"

Xu Zhiqian choked up and said: "I was really scared just now, I was afraid that I would let Aunt Liu get nothing, if the government didn't award the house to Aunt Liu in the end, Aunt Liu might be accused of fraud, if that's the case... "

Just now when Liang Dong and Naerbi Li Lei went up to fight together, she was at a loss for what to do. She was at a disadvantage, and her heart was completely wrapped in fear.

She always thought that if she lost the lawsuit, Aunt Liu might be convicted.

She was terrified.

In the past, she followed Zhang Fei to court, with Zhang Fei at the front, and Zhang Fei was always calm and in the mood to chat with her, she could not feel this kind of pressure.

When she stood alone in the courtroom, she felt this pressure, which made her breathless for a while.

Zhang Fei gently pulled her into his arms, but he said angrily, "I'm really stupid, I should have let you try in court long ago, why bother talking so much."

Xu Zhiqian buried her head in his arms and sobbed, "You just have to laugh, I'll let you laugh enough today."