Greetings, Mister Principal: Wave-particle 2 iconicity
"Light is a wave and a particle."
As soon as Reiner said this, mixed exclamations came from the entire conference room.
Most mages thought that Reiner would come up with some earth-shattering theories, or simply end the war between the wave theory and the particle theory, but unexpectedly, he came up with an answer that seemed a bit "ridiculous".
Both a wave and a particle?
What a joke.
Let’s not talk about whether there is really any material in this world that is both a wave and a particle. This answer itself seems to make fun of the debate in the mage community for decades.
Even if you don’t insist that light is a wave or a particle, the ambiguous answer given by Reiner is difficult to accept.
"Linard Ingle, are you serious?"
The legendary mage Carl David advocated the particle theory. At first, when he saw Reiner’s photoelectric effect paper, he thought Reiner was a member of the particle school. However, he did not expect that in just two papers, he betrayed The particle sect gave such an extremely ridiculous answer.
"Is there really matter in this world, which is both waves and particles?"
"Now we have it, Sir David."
Reiner replied in a deep voice, neither humble nor arrogant.
"Haha, I know that it is difficult for the photoelectric effect to coexist with interference and diffraction, but isn't our goal to use a complete theory to explain two contradictory experimental phenomena clearly? As it is now, we don't solve the problem. , but choose a compromise method to avoid the problem, which is not what a mage should do."
Just like his practical style, Carl David speaks arrogantly without caring about the feelings of others. Before he became a legendary mage, David often quarreled with others. The result of the quarrel was a magic competition, and the winner It will always be David. Once he reaches the realm of legend, no one will dare to argue with him.
Compared with using his mouth, Carl David prefers to use his fists to reason.
Of course, his current refutation of Reiner's words is not simply unreasonable. David believes that accepting Reiner's statement is the last resort, which represents the failure and compromise of mages in exploring this world.
He actually doesn’t care whether light is a particle or a wave. What he cares about is how to use a complete theory to explain the various characteristics of light, whether it is a wave or a particle. If he can do it, it means that the mage They have the most in-depth understanding of the nature of light.
Having both characteristics at the same time is quite frustrating.
Just like the problem of black body radiation, the thermal radiation displacement law and Oaklander-David law hold true in the high-frequency and low-frequency fields respectively, but will fail in the opposite frequency domain. Before the emergence of Stein's formula, the wizards Using two sets of formulas at high frequencies and low frequencies, we can only get approximate curves. How similar is this to the predicament that the nature of light is in today?
As the co-initiator of the Oaklander-David law, Carl David, who has personally experienced the bitterness of it, refutes this ambiguous statement in this way.
"Don't add entities if it's not necessary. This is what you said, Reiner, so why add a characteristic to light."
His Excellency Lanchester Stannion also spoke, and his words made many mages nod their heads. Although the statement that light has two properties at the same time can solve almost all problems related to light currently encountered, with one It would be too hasty to explain experimental phenomena using hypotheses.
"If it is true, as you said, that light has two characteristics at the same time, then what does the essence of light look like and how does it usually exist? Could it be that it changes its own characteristics because of the different things it encounters? Features?"
Alan von Norbert Reinhardt asked questions in an angry voice. He was not that aggressive, but the questions he raised were also thought-provoking.
Indeed, the existence of matter should be certain. How can matter change its characteristics due to different observation methods? This is like light itself having a will, which is contrary to the long-term research phenomenon of mages.
"Linard Ingle, you'd better explain your point of view with experimental results. If there is experimental support, then we should accept the conclusion no matter how absurd it is."
Finally, Herman Braggs’ words gradually silenced the discussion in the venue. People looked at Reiner thoughtfully, waiting for his proof.
Hall looked at Reiner Ingle from a distance, being questioned by many legendary mages, but there was no trace of panic on Reiner's face, only calmness and confidence.
This is a more serious situation than the time of Lord Isaris Ebdon.
At that time, His Excellency Isharis Ebdon was still a high-level mage. He had different opinions with several other high-level mage, so they argued in the high-level council. The only difference was that at that time, no one could Explain whether the three laws of kinematics are true.
Now, Reiner is facing seven legendary mages, dozens of high-level mages, and hundreds of mid-level mages.
Almost everyone disagrees with his argument, and anyone here can give examples to refute it.
Can Reiner prove it?
How on earth is he going to prove it?
"In my hypothesis, light is a special substance with the characteristics of waves and particles. When light is observed from different angles, the light will show different characteristics."
Reiner said, everyone was silent.
"When light shines on a metal plate, the particle nature causes the outermost electrons of the light quantum excimer atoms to generate an electric current. When the light passes through a small hole or a double slit, the wave nature allows it to undergo diffraction and interference phenomena. It is because light has these two properties at the same time that such a contradictory phenomenon occurs."
Reiner's words made many mages unable to hold back, because his statement seemed to be a simple summary, but the real experimental part was not mentioned at all. Some even thought that Reiner was just stalling for time.
"The reason why I say these seemingly nonsense things is to prepare you mentally to prevent the theory I am going to talk about from causing some unfortunate accidents. I must emphasize to everyone, forget what you have said before. The world of cognition starts from a blank, follow my rhythm to re-understand light, otherwise, unpredictable situations are likely to occur, you know what I am talking about."
Looking around the audience, Reiner said calmly and calmly.
His words caused an inexplicable panic among the mid-level mages, because the meaning of Reiner's words was self-evident, and his subsequent display may very well lead to cognitive collapse!
Will Reiner propose a subversive theory?
The high-level mages were also a little uneasy~IndoMTL.com~The atmosphere in the venue was like an empty valley where a storm was about to come, solemn and silent, as if just one spark would completely detonate it.
After a pause, Reiner continued.
"Actually, as Lord Lanchester said, don't add entities unless necessary. We don't need to impose an attribute on light in order to explain the contradictory phenomena of light in different experiments. So, what I want to say Yes, wave-particle duality is not just a property unique to light, but a property shared by microscopic particles. I will provide experimental proof of this."
Reiner said calmly, looking directly at the legendary mages, as if the people in the audience were not academic masters, but his own students.
"At this venue."
https://
Genius website address:. Mobile version reading URL: