I’m Really a Superstar Chapter 323: [One by one explanation of logical errors! 】

A little quiet.

Many people are digesting Zhang Ye.

Zhang Ye said: "Everyone thinks about it, I also drink saliva, haha."

Zhang Ye is brought up with a water cup, unscrewing the lid of the thermos cup, which contains Pu'er tea, which was just brewed with the teacher's office when it came over. The water temperature was still hot. Familiar with the taste of Pu'er, drinking not only warms his stomach in winter, but also helps him relax his mind and adjust his thinking. Of course, Zhang Ye has always been very relaxed.On the stage, in the venue of thousands of people, so many reporters, so many cameras, so many students Teacher, and so many Literature colleagues who came to tear down the stage, he was a little bit Don't be nervous, the expression of drinking tea lightly, as if on the head of one's own's house, look like that, if you give him a bed on the table, he would dare to lie down.

Only this calm, few people can do it.

Changed to another Peking University lecturer, not to mention the lecturer, even those professors who have been conducting lectures and public classes all year round have to be so nervous and urgent in the face of such a big battle.

But Zhang Ye doesn't.

This is the basic quality of a professional Host.

There are more reasons for Zhang Ye character-he has always had such a heartless and heartless mindset. God didn't give him a good face or a good figure, but there were losses and gains. This calmness and not being frightened is probably compensation for him.

Drink the water.

Lesson continues.

Zhang Ye held the microphone and asked, "Do you have any questions about the structural problems and analysis of Lou Men" I just explained?

No one speaks.

"Little Song?" Zhang Ye called.

Senior Song got up and said, "I need to digest it first."

Zhang Ye has ordered a favorite speaker, "Little Zhou?"

Zhou Xuechang smiled bitterly: "I have to listen to it again, I won't speak for the time being."

A smile, Zhang Ye said: "Okay, I'll tell you next ..."

"Wait a minute." The red scholar Teacher Yang in the first row of seats finally spoke out. He was from beginning to end, and he couldn't help but stand up. Otherwise, it looks like their Senior experts are The junior said that he was dizzy and let their face go, so even if Teacher Yang has not studied the problem of the structure of the red building, he also refuted it with one's own, avoided the structure, and changed a method. Sitting with a microphone, he said, "I don't agree with the structure of the so-called Dream of the Red Mansion Nine by Twelve. The structure of what you said may be just a coincidence. The academic circles have long concluded that Mr. Cao Xueqin was seriously ill in his later years or for other reasons. He made some mistakes in writing, which is also the reason why Jia Baoyu's personality has changed.

Zhang Ye laughed: "How did the red academia study it and what conclusions it reached, I do n’t know, and I do n’t agree with it. My point of view is just the opposite of everyone. The problem is not the reason why he was seriously ill and then confused. The 108th Dream of the Whole House is also existence. Cao Xueqin already has almost finished writing this, which can be seen from the rich and poems of my class yesterday. . "

Teacher Yang waited for his sentence, he smiled, and asked, "Well, now that you said that, then I would like to ask, you said that only the first eighty times of the current dream" is Cao Xueqin's. In the original pen, Mr. Cao also made some low-level mistakes without physical reasons. OK, let's talk about the first eighty times according to your thinking. You just said it, can you explain it? "

Zhang Ye frankly said, "Of course."

Another youth Redologists said: "Are you sure?"

"Oh, I'm sure, you can ask." Zhang Ye it does not matter said: "But there is a sentence I said first, it is roughly eighty times before, not eighty times."

Teacher Yang sniffed and said, "Okay, how do you explain the death of Lin Ruhai time?"

The young man Redologists also poured fuel on the fire: "I also asked one, Qin Keqing's illness and death were at odds with the verdict of the atlas. What do you say?"

Zhang Ye didn't answer, but said, "Are there any more? You can say it together."

The Yan Yu, who has the highest status in the Literature community, also spoke, "Jia's birthday, and the age of Jia Baoyu involved in it."

I lost a bunch of questions

This is all that the red academia cannot explain at this time

Okay, don't you just explain everything? Then you explain it to us

At this moment, the people in the Literature community finally attacked Zhang Ye for the first time. Originally, on the structural issue, they could not find any breakthrough to attack Zhang Ye, because Zhang Ye really surprised them too much. In this structure, What was said on the field was perfect, and it could even be said to be incisive, and once again it was a major breakthrough in the study of Red Science, so they really could not find an excuse for attack, but in their opinion, Zhang Ye was too arrogant, and even said everything He can explain the logical problems. Now, people in the Literature world also have a breakthrough.

About seven or eight questions, all of them are major logical errors, and they are the kind of dead problems, which ca n’t be solved after years of research. They want to see what Zhang Ye says

Peking University students are also uproaring.

"It's bad"

"This is Redologists take action"

"Is Teacher Zhang explained? Impossible"

"It's interesting to be tit-for-tat, this is interesting"

"Can Teacher Zhang Ye work?"

Some students are excited and wait to see the excitement. Some students, such as Yao Mi, were very worried and looked at Zhang Ye with a worried look. Even Xue Zhou and other students who have been asking questions and have been looking for opportunities to refute the Zhang Ye argument are worried about Zhang Ye. Admittedly, they are very skeptical of Zhang Ye's point of view, but in the final analysis, they are still in their one's own class. It was an exchange between their students and Teacher.It was a Literature disagreement that occurred within Peking University, but the people in the Literature community were outsiders who came to "smash the field." They are good for Zhou Xuechang, Zhang Ye, and Peking University. People, there are still unanimous emotions.

Zhang Ye look at them, "Just that?"

Professor Ma Hengyuan sneered, "You answer these questions before you talk."

Zhang Ye nodded, "Okay, then I'll answer it, but Vice President Yan's question, I will put it aside for a while, I will answer the previous one first."

Yan Yu glanced at him.

Teacher Yang said: "Okay, you say we listen."

No one believes that Zhang Ye can explain it.

They don't know. Zhang Ye had long guessed that they would ask these things. After all, the study of Red Science is just like three axes, and there are only a few logical errors. I ca n’t ask anything else, so I guess very well. Please look at the screen, first look at the information I gave. "Zhang Ye and Peking University staff exchanged a bit, the other party immediately found the information and put it on the projection.

Two Young Lady?

Jia Yingchun's information?

Zhang Ye glanced at everyone, saying: "Jia Yingchun is very familiar to everyone, you should also know her origin, but I Believe has really studied Lou Dream." The description of Jia Yingchun's life in the ancient texts passed down is completely different. My information here is a record of several ancient texts, let's take a look.

The second Young Lady was made by pardoning his ex-wife.

Second Young Lady comes from the father's wife.

Second Young Lady is from the former wife of Zheng Dad.

Second Young Lady was born by the pardon of the father.

Second Young Lady is the daughter of the father's pardon, and the father of the government raises his own daughter.

Several Redologistss are frowning.I don't understand why Zhang Ye gave this information. Second, this is still an area they are not familiar with. They have indeed seen these things, such as Yan Yu, such as Teacher Yang, and even Ma Hengyuan. I know, but because of the relative bias, Jia Yingchun is not a particularly important role for them, so there is not much research on it in the red academia, and because there are too many logical problems in Lou Meng, there are more and bigger Other logical errors lead them to discover and study. Who cares about discussing the life of a it does not matter character? This Zhang Ye, how is it given that they are not good at it?

Zhang Ye said, and then said: "The five ancient texts are all different. We know that the origins of the ancient manuscripts in Honglou are well-founded. Is this the wrong copy? Obviously not, if the first four ancient texts It is wrong to copy wrongly, so how can the fifth ancient text be read wrongly? This is completely impossible. The only explanation for this complicated result is that this is Cao Xueqin's repeated consideration and coming back. The ground is in changing, I haven't thought about it, and it has not been finalized, so it will be passed down so many completely different ancient texts. There is no doubt about this I Believe "

Professor Zeng nodded slightly.

Teacher Yang and Ma Hengyuan have no expressions and sit quietly.

Zhang Ye said: "So with this foundation and cognition, everyone's problems have been solved. Cao Xueqin was not sick and rewritten. Some of the so-called logical errors are in the beginning. Is it heavy? My mind is confused? So, this is actually that Cao Xueqin has not finished changing, and has not yet been finalized. The problem of Lin Ruhai's death time, Qin Keqing's illness and death and the fifth round of atlas judgement are all subtle. Sexual problems, that is just just the ending of individual characters changing and some simple text changes.

Teacher Yang rebutted: "Don't you say the 108th floor dream" is finished? "

“It ’s finished, it ’s almost finished.” Zhang Ye said: “But it does n’t mean that it is finalized. I believe that friends who have written books should have experience in this area. I happen to be an author, so I know what's inside. Even if I don't talk about writing a book, the students here should be able to appreciate it. When you write an essay, when you write a dissertation, will it be finalized? "

Peking University students are shaking their heads.

"No."

"Yes, changing?"

“Well, I ’ll definitely have to look back a few times and retouch.”

Zhang Ye smiled, "So is Cao Xueqin."

Yang Teacher Leng sneered: "If you explain it this way, you can also say the logical problem after 80 years, how can you prove that it was written by two people?"

Zhang Ye shook his hand and said, "It's not like this. It's not a concept at all. The logical error after 80 times is not a simple change of a few words and a few paragraphs, and it comes back, but it involves the whole book. The problem of the conception involves the error of the core idea.It is difficult for us to believe that Cao Xueqin planned to write Jiafu's piece of white land, which was really pure, but suddenly he wanted to write Jiafu's family revival. A loving old grandmother, the author suddenly wanted to turn her into a cold parent; Jia Baoyu was originally 'the world's incompetent is the first, and the ancient and the modern are not incomparable, but the author suddenly wanted to let him be his ancestor. Will suddenly change from a person who sees the world, to a character who is keen on fame and honor, Guangzong Yaozu.

Zhang Ye's aggravated intonation sentences make those Redologists speechless.

Zhang Ye said: "When you write a paper, you will go back to the details of changing, change the text, and adjust some writing errors, but will you change the core idea and central point of view of the paper? It is impossible to do this. Rhetoric is simply unreasonable "

I really explained it

And the explanation is reasonable

Teacher Yang was a little dull, and Meng Dongguo was cold.They didn't expect it. This time, Zhang Ye faced these errors that couldn't be explained at all, and didn't tell from the content of the book, but changed the angle again. Explained from the logical thinking of an author's writing

Good mouth

Good iron tooth copper tooth

Yan Yu narrowed his eyes, "Can mother Jia's problem be explained in the same way? I don't understand why you should take out my questionnaire."

Zhang Ye laughed: "If I am an ordinary reader, an ordinary researcher, Jia ’s age can be explained in this way-the author has not come and changing, everyone will certainly accept this explanation, and you do n’t have to ask the roots and do more. But I can't, because my current status is Teacher. I must be rigorous academically. The reason why I have to list Jia ’s problems is because Jia ’s situation is special and cannot be generalized with those previous explanations. Said, that is irresponsible to my students "

"Special?"

"What is special?"

"It feels the same?"

"Yes, isn't Mother Jia also a birthday and age problem?"

Peking University students are talking.

Zhang Ye said in detail, "If you do n’t mention this, I did n’t want to talk about it, but since I ’m talking about it, I ’ll talk about the mother ’s birthday. It ’s the beginning of August. On the third day, it ’s sixty-two times after the Festival of Lights, that is, the old lady and sister Bao? The two original texts are completely Mao Dun, but according to my research, based on the coincidence of Baodi ’s birthday, I judge six Twelve times after the Festival of Lights, the birthday is the birthday that matches the prototype of the life. Another reason is that the 39th time has the mother mother ’s words: 'Old relatives, how old are you this year?', Liu Grandma was busy standing and answering "I'm seventy-five this year. Mother Jia said: It's so old and still so healthy. How many years older than me. I don't know how to move when I am so old. It also shows that mother Jia Is not more than seventy-four years old, and the text of the seventy-one days is the 80th anniversary of the mother ’s day on the third day of August, "

Everyone remembers it

There are indeed these original words

Zhang Ye summed up the conclusion and said, "So I can be sure that the third day of August is made up and eighty years old? This age is a leap, integrated, and fictitious, obviously not the mother's true birthday age. Therefore, the text of the seventy-one times ... was changed later, which is why I just emphasized that I can explain the logic error of 'eighty, eighty times, because Cao Xueqin's first eighty words' The manuscript has also been lost, tampered with, and mistakenly copied situation.This is the case with the mother ’s birthday. This paragraph or this time is as lost as the eighty times. It is Gao Ling or an unknown name. At the time of writing, the one's own changes were added so that such a major flaw appeared, so this flaw is different from the other flaws just now, so naturally you have to speak it out separately

Reasonable and justified

There are original reasons

Zhang Ye shocked everyone again

The reporters do n’t understand at all, even if they have watched Lou Meng. ”Many things Zhang Ye said they ca n’t react for a while, they feel too esoteric and too detailed, but they do n’t understand it does not mean they wo n’t Look at it. When you see the expressions of the Writer and Redologists in the first row, the reporters can understand it even if they are stupid. The interpretation and analysis of Teacher Zhang Ye is very powerful.

"It makes sense"

"This really explains the smooth flow"

"Are there any other authors after 80?"

Yao Mi is very happy, Hee Hee laughs, Uncle Zhang is too fierce

The brothers Li Ying and Li Li next to her were also said to be heart-beating. The perspective of Teacher Zhang Ye is really impacting their inherent cognition.

Wu Zeqing smiles silently.

Chang Kaige Professor Zeng They kept nodding.

Other Peking University lecturers and outside history experts are also thinking

In the face of the logic problem that has always been plagued by the red academia, Zhang Ye has not refused to come, and it has made most sense in one breath.

Literature people also look at me, I look at you.

Yesterday, I watched the lecture video on the Peking University official website. They didn't feel anything, but I only knew it when I arrived at the scene today. Zhang Ye is really too eloquent. Several people were really surprised by the opinions and explanations proposed by Zhang Ye. Zhang Ye gave them a new idea they never thought of.

And the thing that most shocked these Literature people is not the analysis and explanation of Zhang Ye from various ideas, but the Zhang Ye's familiarity with Lou Meng, which is even better than those who have studied the Red House for more than 10 years and 20 years. You also need to be familiar with the fact that you have memorized Lou Meng from beginning to end? Zhang Ye has just a long-length analysis and the original quotes, it is almost unbelievable, but there is no script, but even the screen and materials have not seen the huge amount of quotes and information mentioned in the manuscript, but the specific text has been Zhang Ye It ’s not bad to say a word

The first time.

The first few sentences.

The text of the specific paragraph.

That was to say that I did n’t hit one of my babies. This is too exaggerated in their eyes. Don't say that the red scholars they came from, no one in the red academia can be in this group. To the extent of Zhang Ye, no matter whether the Zhang Ye perspective is correct, this person definitely understands the Dream of the House, and may be more thorough and thorough than their experts in many places.

Having this fact, half of these people in the Literature world are even more embarrassed.

But after the embarrassment, Redologists Teacher Yang is still well-founded. In his opinion, Zhang Ye started from saying the phrase "I can explain it", Zhang Ye was unable to justify it, because there is one in the Redologists study that nobody has The logic question mentioned is really unsolved

Typos?

Not finalized?

Nothing can explain that problem